Frontier Orbitals and Charges Approaches in Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution: The Cases of Anisole and Benzaldehyde
Lucia Emanuele, Rocco Racioppi, Maurizio D’Auria
Organics · pp. 13–13 · Published 4 Mar 2026
10.3390/org7010013Abstract
The study aimed to verify the possible use of DFT calculation in the prediction of the orientation in electrophilic aromatic substitution. An activated ortho/para orienting substrate, and a deactivated meta orienting substrate, were used in DFT calculations using B3LYP, B3PW91, BPV86, CAM-B3LP, HCTH, HSEH1PBE, LSDA, MPW1PW91, PBEPBE, TPSSTPSS, and WB97XD functionals. The results showed that the reactivity of anisole can be adequately described considering charge control in reaction performed in hard conditions (nitration), while frontier orbital control can play a role in reactions performed in softer conditions (chlorination). Nitration of benzaldehyde can be rationalized through Hirshfeld charges analysis. Neither the frontier orbital nor Mulliken charges approach adequately account for behavior observed in chlorination of benzaldehyde. The effect of different basis sets was tested performing calculations with B3LYP functional and aug-cc-pVDZ, 6-311G+(d,p), aug-cc-pVQZ, DGTZVP, and LanL2DZ basis sets. For anisole, all basis sets provided a HOMO electron density distribution consistent with experimental reactivity; Hirshfeld charges analysis consistently reproduced the observed reactivity of anisole across all tested basis sets. All the basis sets were able to explain the observed reactivity of benzaldehyde in hard experimental condition, while they failed to give a correct description when a softer reagent was used.
References (52)
- 1 Koerner, 1874, Studi sull’isomeria delle così dette sostanze aromatiche a sei atomi di carbonio
- 2 Karrer, P. (1963). Lehrbuch der Organishen Chemie, Georg Thieme Verlag.
- 3 Wheland, 1942, A quantum mechanical investigation of the orientation of substitution in aromatic molecules [DOI]
- 4 Olah, 1971, Aromatic substitution. XXVIII. Mechanism of electrophilic aromatic substitutions [DOI]
- 5 Stuyver, 2019, Electrophilic aromatic substitution reactions: Mechanistic landascape, electrostatic and electric-field control of reaction rates, and mechanistic crossovers [DOI]
- 6 Galabov, 2016, Electrophilic aromatic substitution: New insights into an old class of reactions [DOI]
- 7 Domingo, L.R. (2016). Molecular Electron Density Theory: A Modern View of Reactivity in Organic Chemistry. Molecules, 21. [DOI]
- 8 Walkimar, 2006, Electrophilic Aromatic Nitration: Understanding Its Mechanism and Substituent Effects [DOI]
- 9 Schwabe, 2008, Theoretical Description of Substituent Effects in Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution Reactions [DOI]
- 10 Fievez, 2011, Regioselectivity in Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution: Insights from Interaction Energy Decomposition Potentials [DOI]
- 11 Szatylowicz, 2019, Aromaticity: A story of 150 years of development
- 12 Starmenkovic, 2021, An analysis of electrophilic aromatic substitution: A “complex approach” [DOI]
- 13 Martins, 2026, Myths and Truths About Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution: The Particular Case of Fluorobenzene [DOI]
- 14 Fukui, 1952, A molecular orbital theory of reactivity of aromatic hydrocarbons [DOI]
- 15 Seeman, 2022, Kenichi Fukui, Frontier Molecular Orbital Theory, and the Woodward-Hoffmann Rules. Part II. A Sleeping Beauty in Chemistry [DOI]
- 16 Elliott, 1982, Quantitative frontier orbital theory: Part I. Electrophilic aromatic substitution [DOI]
- 17 Klopman, 1968, Chemical reactivity and the concept of charge- and frontier-controlled reactions [DOI]
- 18 Salem, 1968, Intermolecular orbital theory of the interaction between conjugated systems. I. General theory [DOI]
- 19 Salem, 1968, Intermolecular orbital theory of the interaction between conjugated systems. II. Thermal and photochemical cycloaddition [DOI]
- 20 Liu, 2014, Where does the electron go? The nature of ortho/para and meta group directing in electrophilic aromatic substitution [DOI]
- 21 Emanuele, L., and D’Auria, M. (2025). Limitations of frontier orbital and charge approaches in the description of electrophilic aromatic substitution. Organics, 6. [DOI]
- 22 Hirshfeld, 1977, Bonded-atom fragments for describing molecular charge densities [DOI]
- 23 Mulliken, 1955, Electronic population analysis on LCAO-MO molecular wave functions [DOI]
- 24 Manz, 2020, Seven confluence principles: A case study of standardized statistical analysis for 26 methods that assign net atomic charges in molecules [DOI]
- 25 Saha, 2009, Are the Hirshfeld and Mulliken population analysis schemes consistent with chemical intuition? [DOI]
- 26 Frisch, M.J., Trucks, G.W., Schlegel, H.B., Scuseria, G.E., Robb, M.A., Cheeseman, J.R., Scalmani, G., Barone, V., Mennucci, B., and Petersson, G.A. (2009). Gaussian 09, Revision A.1, Gaussian, Inc.
- 27 Becke, 1993, Density-functional thermochemistry. III. The role of exact exchange [DOI]
- 28 Perdew, 1992, Accurate and simple analytic representation of the electron-gas correlation energy [DOI]
- 29 Perdew, 1986, Density-functional approximation for the correlation energy of the inhomogeneous electron gas
- 30 Yanai, 2004, A new hybrid exchange-correlation functional using the Coulomb-attenuating method (CAM-B3LYP) [DOI]
- 31 Boese, 2002, New exchange-correlation density functionals: The role of the kinetic-energy density [DOI]
- 32 Heyd, 2004, Efficient hybrid density functional calculations in solids: Assessment of the Heyd–Scuseria–Ernzerhof screened Coulomb hybrid functional [DOI]
- 33 Heyd, 2004, Assessment and validation of a screened Coulomb hybrid density functional [DOI]
- 34 Heyd, 2005, Energy band gaps and lattice parameters evaluated with the Heyd-Scuseria-Ernzerhof screened hybrid functional [DOI]
- 35 Heyd, 2003, Hybrid functionals based on a screened Coulomb potential [DOI]
- 36 Henderson, 2009, Can short-range hybrids describe long-range-dependent properties? [DOI]
- 37 Izmaylov, 2006, Efficient evaluation of short-range Hartree-Fock exchange in large molecules and periodic systems [DOI]
- 38 Krukau, 2006, Influence of the exchange screening parameter on the performance of screened hybrid functionals [DOI]
- 39 Vosko, 1980, Accurate spin-dependent electron liquid correlation energies for local spin density calculations: A critical analysis [DOI]
- 40 Adamo, 1998, Exchange functionals with improved long-range behavior and adiabatic connection methods without adjustable parameters: The mPW and mPW1PW models [DOI]
- 41 Ernzerhof, 1998, Generalized gradient approximation to the angle- and system-averaged exchange hole [DOI]
- 42 Tao, 2003, Climbing the Density Functional Ladder: Nonempirical Meta–Generalized Gradient Approximation Designed for Molecules and Solids [DOI]
- 43 Staroverov, 2003, Comparative assessment of a new nonempirical density functional: Molecules and hydrogen-bonded complexes [DOI]
- 44 Chai, 2008, Long-range corrected hybrid density functionals with damped atom–atom dispersion corrections [DOI]
- 45 Dunning, 1989, Gaussian basis sets for use in correlated molecular calculations. I. The atoms boron through neon and hydrogen [DOI]
- 46 Parr, R.G., and Yang, W. (1989). Density Functional Theory of Atoms and Molecules, Oxford University Press.
- 47 Peterson, 1994, Benchmark calculations with correlated molecular wave functions. IV. The classical barrier height of the H+H2→H2+H reaction [DOI]
- 48 Godbout, 1992, Optimization of Gaussian-type basis sets for local spin density functional calculations. Part I. Boron through neon, optimization technique and validation [DOI]
- 49 Schaefer, 1977, Gaussian Basis Sets for Molecular Calculations
- 50 Stock, L.M. (1968). Aromatic Substitution Reactions, Prentice-Hall.
- 51 Davey, W., and Gwilt, J.R. (1950). The preparation of the mononitrobenzaldehydes. J. Chem. Soc., 204–208. [DOI]
- 52 Erdmann, 1890, Ueber gechlorte Abkömmlinge des Benzaldehyds [DOI]
Cited by 1
1 citation reported by external sources — individual citing-article records aren't available to list yet.
Related research
- A Novel Catalytic Synthesis of Flavones under Autoclave Conditions and Comparative Study of Anti-cancer Activity — shares topic coverage
- Thermostability and in-vitro Antibacterial Activity of Aqueous Extracts of Tetrapleura tetraptera Pods on Multidrug Resistant Clinical Isolates — shares topic coverage
- Acute Toxicity, Phytochemistry and Anti-diarrheal Effects of Celtis integrifolia Lam. Aqueous Leaf Extract in Wistar Albino Rats — shares topic coverage
- Understanding the Reactivity of Trimethylsilyldiazoalkanes Participating in [3+2] Cycloaddition Reactions towards Diethylfumarate with a Molecular Electron Density Theory Perspective — shares topic coverage
- Understanding the Origin of the Regioselectivity in Non-Polar [3+2] Cycloaddition Reactions through the Molecular Electron Density Theory — shares topic coverage
Article metrics
Real usage data collected on this platform.
0
Page views
0
PDF downloads
0
Outbound clicks
1
Citations
Views by country
Approximate, from request IP at view time — not citizenship or institution. Countries with fewer than 5 views are grouped as "Other".
No views recorded yet.
Traffic sources
Referring site, by host.
No traffic recorded yet.
Views and downloads exclude known bots/crawlers. Citations combines this platform's own DOI-resolved index with each external source's own reported total — see Cited by above for individually listed citing works. Last refreshed 0 seconds ago.