The Unexpected Harm of Same-sex Marriage: A Critical Appraisal, Replication and Re-analysis of Wainright and Patterson’s Studies of Adolescents with Same-sex Parents
Journal of Education, Society and Behavioural Science · pp. 1–22 · Published 8 Aug 2015
10.9734/BJESBS/2015/19337Abstract
Aims: To critique, replicate and re-analyze Wainright and Patterson’s three studies of adolescents with same-sex parents, which conclude, based on representative population data, that such children suffer no disadvantages. Methodology: After replicating Wainright and Patterson’s sample and analyses using the National Longitudinal Survey of Adolescent Health, Wave I, (n = 20,745), re-examination of the same-sex parent sample finds that 27 of the 44 cases are misidentified heterosexual parents; they did not adjust for survey design and clustering; and ignored 99 percent of the baseline by using a small matched sample for comparison. Outcomes are re-analyzed after correcting these problems, using OLS, logistic regression and Firth (bias-adjusted) regression models. Results: The adolescents with same-sex parents experience significantly lower autonomy and higher anxiety, but also better school performance, than do adolescents with opposite-sex parents. Comparing unmarried to (self-described) married same-sex parents, above-average child depressive symptoms rises from 50% to 88%; daily fearfulness or crying rises from 5% to 32%; grade point average declines from 3.6 to 3.4; and child sex abuse by parent rises from zero to 38%. The longer a child has been with same-sex parents, the greater the harm. Conclusion: Children with same-sex parents experience significant disadvantages, but also some advantages, compared to those with man-woman parents. Although opposite-sex marriage is associated with improved outcomes on a wide range of child well-being measures, same-sex marriage is associated with lower outcomes. Further work is needed to determine the relative influences of instability, duration, and marriage to these findings.
References (23)
- 1 The CES-D Scale [DOI]
- 2 Psychometric Properties of the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire [DOI]
- 3 Bias reduction of maximum likelihood estimates [DOI]
- 4 (How) Does the Sexual Orientation of Parents Matter? [DOI]
- 5 Psychosocial Adjustment, School Outcomes, and Romantic Relationships of Adolescents With Same-Sex Parents [DOI]
- 6 How different are the adult children of parents who have same-sex relationships? Findings from the New Family Structures Study [DOI]
- 7 Nontraditional families and childhood progress through school [DOI]
- 8 Delinquency, victimization, and substance use among adolescents with female same-sex parents. [DOI]
- 9 Peer relations among adolescents with female same-sex parents. [DOI]
- 10 Child Well-Being in Same-Sex Parent Families: Review of Research Prepared for American Sociological Association Amicus Brief [DOI]
- 11 A Population‐Based Study of Alcohol Use in Same‐Sex and Different‐Sex Unions [DOI]
- 12 Emotional Problems among Children with Same-sex Parents: Difference by Definition [DOI]
- 13 ‘Kids are just cruel anyway’: Lesbian and gay parents' talk about homophobic bullying [DOI]
- 14 Same-Sex Cohabitors and Health [DOI]
- 15 Efforts to maintain a ‘just great’ story: Lesbian parents’ talk about encounters with professionals in fertility clinics and maternal and child healthcare services [DOI]
- 16 High school graduation rates among children of same-sex households [DOI]
- 17 Parent Practices and Home-School Partnerships: A Differential Effect for Children with Same-Sex Coupled Parents? [DOI]
- 18 Nontraditional Families and Childhood Progress Through School: A Comment on Rosenfeld [DOI]
- 19 Lesbian and Gay Parents and their Children: A Social Science Perspective [DOI]
- 20 Cigarette Smoking in Same-Sex and Different-Sex Unions: The Role of Socioeconomic and Psychological Factors [DOI]
- 21 Jephthah's Daughter
- 22 Guidelines for Analyzing Add Health Data [DOI]
- 23 LITERATURE CITED [DOI]
Cited by 30
Walter R. Schumm · Psychological Reports · 2016
Walter R. Schumm, Duane W. Crawford · The Linacre Quarterly · 2023
D. Paul Sullins · Depression Research and Treatment · 2016
Deni Mazrekaj, Kristof De Witte, Sofie Cabus · American Sociological Review · 2020
D. Paul Sullins · Depression Research and Treatment · 2016
Simmin Bawa, Jesha Jani, Shalini Nisar · Edumania-An International Multidisciplinary Journal · 2024
Deni Mazrekaj, Yuxuan Jin · Humanities and Social Sciences Communications · 2023
Paul Cameron, Kirk M. Cameron, Kay Proctor · Marriage & Family Review · 2017
Walter R. Schumm · Comprehensive Psychology · 2015
Walter R. Schumm · Comprehensive Psychology · 2015
Showing 12 of 30 known citations — external sources report more than can currently be individually listed.
Related research
- Bias in Recruited Sample Research on Children with Same-Sex Parents Using the Strength and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) — shares topic coverage
- Emotional Problems among Children with Same-Sex Parents: Difference by Definition — shares topic coverage
- Child Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in Same-Sex Parent Families in the United States: Prevalence and Comorbidities — shares topic coverage
Article metrics
Real usage data collected on this platform.
90
Page views
0
PDF downloads
39
Outbound clicks
30
Citations
Views over time
Views by country
Approximate, from request IP at view time — not citizenship or institution. Countries with fewer than 5 views are grouped as "Other".
Traffic sources
Referring site, by host.
Views and downloads exclude known bots/crawlers. Citations combines this platform's own DOI-resolved index with each external source's own reported total — see Cited by above for individually listed citing works. Last refreshed 0 seconds ago.