Critically Evaluating the Effectively Maintained Inequality Hypothesis
Journal of Education, Society and Behavioural Science · pp. 1–9 · Published 22 Mar 2016
10.9734/BJESBS/2016/24563Abstract
This paper uses data for England to test the effectively maintained inequality (EMI) hypothesis that individuals from ‘high’ and ‘low’ socioeconomic backgrounds have qualitatively different modal educational destinations at a given educational level. In so doing, the paper highlights how a focus on modal educational destinations seriously detracts from the usefulness of the EMI hypothesis as a basis for identifying qualitative educational inequalities. First, tests of the EMI hypothesis are shown to be of questionable reliability because they involve calculating the predicted probabilities of different educational destinations based on ultimately arbitrary operationalisations of ‘high’ and ‘low’ socioeconomic background, with more polarised formulations being more likely to find in favour of EMI. Second, tests of the EMI hypothesis are shown to be of questionable validity in that it is possible to find in favour of EMI even when the degree of qualitative inequality is negligible and to find against EMI even when the degree of qualitative inequality is substantial. These limitations have been recognised by the originator of the EMI hypothesis but dismissed as unimportant. However, this paper argues that these limitations are so serious that analysts seeking to identify qualitative inequalities in education should discard the focus on modal educational destinations advocated by the EMI hypothesis.
References (21)
- 1 Generalized Ordered Logit/Partial Proportional Odds Models for Ordinal Dependent Variables [DOI]
- 2 Effectively Maintained Inequality: Education Transitions, Track Mobility, and Social Background Effects [DOI]
- 3 Social Background and School Continuation Decisions [DOI]
- 4 Higher Education and Social Class: Issues of Exclusion and Inclusion
- 5 How fair is access to more prestigious UK universities? [DOI]
- 6 Expansion, differentiation, and the persistence of social class inequalities in British higher education [DOI]
- 7 Elite Higher Education Admissions in the Arts and Sciences: Is Cultural Capital the Key? [DOI]
- 8 Stratification Theory, Socioeconomic Background, and Educational Attainment [DOI]
- 9 The Returns to Academic and Vocational Qualifications in Britain [DOI]
- 10 Higher Education Outcomes, Graduate Employment and University Performance Indicators [DOI]
- 11 Choice at the end of compulsory schooling: a research review
- 12 Differentiation and social segregation of UK higher education, 1996–2010 [DOI]
- 13 Vocational qualifications and progression to higher education: the case of the 14–19 Diplomas in the English system [DOI]
- 14 Scottish higher education, 1987–2001: expansion through diversion [DOI]
- 15 The Returns to Academic, Vocational and Basic Skills in Britain
- 16 Report №6: Widening participation in higher education for students from lower socio-economic groups and students with disabilities (Расширение возможности получения высшего образования среди выходцев из низших социально-экономических групп населения и лиц с физическими недостатками)
- 17 The determinants of undertaking academic and vocational qualifications in the UK
- 18 Schools, pupils and their characteristics
- 19 University Quality and Graduate Wages in the UK [DOI]
- 20 Impact of university degrees on the lifecycle of earnings:some further analysis
- 21 Graduating and gradations within the middle class: the legacy of an elite higher education
Cited by 17
Maria Raciti, Shireen Motala · Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management · 2025
Manuel T. Valdés · Papers. Revista de Sociologia · 2022
Michael Donnelly, Sol Gamsu · The British Journal of Sociology · 2019
Mukovhe Masutha · Education Sciences · 2022
Claire Callender · Equity Policies in Global Higher Education · 2022
Gill Crozier · Palgrave Studies in Race, Inequality and Social Justice in Education · 2023
Fiona Gogescu · Journal of European Social Policy · 2024
Showing 7 of 17 known citations — external sources report more than can currently be individually listed.
Related research
- Self-Medication Patterns and Practices among Undergraduate Dental Students Compared to Undergraduate Non-Dental Students- A Cross-Sectional Study — shares topic coverage
- Impact of Infection Prevention and Control Education Program on Improving Knowledge, Attitude and Practices of the Healthcare Staff in Hemodialysis Unit at Egyptian Tertiary Care Facility — shares topic coverage
- Knowledge, Attitude and Practice of First Aid and Emergency Care among the Classes Educated in Aurangabad, Maharashtra — shares topic coverage
- Sociodemographic Factors Contributing to Marital Stability — shares topic coverage
- Colorectal Cancer Risk and Prevention Knowledge among Adults Attending Public Health Facilities in Obudu, Cross River State, Nigeria — shares topic coverage
Article metrics
Real usage data collected on this platform.
47
Page views
0
PDF downloads
17
Outbound clicks
17
Citations
Views over time
Views by country
Approximate, from request IP at view time — not citizenship or institution. Countries with fewer than 5 views are grouped as "Other".
Traffic sources
Referring site, by host.
Views and downloads exclude known bots/crawlers. Citations combines this platform's own DOI-resolved index with each external source's own reported total — see Cited by above for individually listed citing works. Last refreshed 0 seconds ago.